You were the Editor
A reporter and photographer are assigned to interview a popular politician who has recently completed an alcohol-recovery program paid for by a group of citizens. He is now pledged to a life of sobriety. One photo taken in his office reveals what appears to be a liquor bottle partially hidden in a bookcase, behind some folders. Do you:
A. Erase the bottle from the picture.
Readers 19%
Editors 5%
B. Publish the picture intact and let readers come to their own conclusions.
Readers 81%
Editors 95%
Readers comments:
"Let the politician explain the bottle. Maybe it's empty. Maybe it's a bookend."
"Don't doctor up photos. Ask the politician about it."
"Forget it. Many recovering alcoholics will leave temptation around to prove themselves."
"Publish no photo."